Leslie Jamison and James Wood – A Prayerful Attention

Leslie Jamison and James Wood
James Wood and Leslie Jamison Photo Credit: Nick Doll

by Bobbie Marquis

When Leslie Jamison and James Wood took the stage on Friday afternoon for the last discussion of the day, a packed auditorium waited to hear how they would address the seminar’s topics. Each has achieved critical acclaim—Leslie for her courageous and beautifully written memoirs and James for his novels and, most notably, his brilliant essays of literary criticism. Clearly, they have both been “Paying Attention.” I wondered how they would speak to “The Novel.”

What followed was an enlightening discussion about their experiences with writing in both fiction and nonfiction. Leslie noted that they, like ships passing in the night, shared a place of “fruitful crossover.” She has a new novel coming out next year, and James has written a memoir about his father that will also be published next year. They spoke about the similarities and constraints and the unique sense of freedom in writing fiction or nonfiction.

James recalled a comment that Colm Toibin had made in his morning discussion about noted LBJ biographer Robert Caro. When Caro wrote about Johnson flying back on the plane and being sworn in as president after Kennedy was assassinated, the details were factually accurate, but more than that, they gave the scene fictional weight. As Colm said, “Caro’s biographies read like novels.”

James gave two other examples of the power of detail, one in nonfiction, one in fiction. In George Orwell’s essay “The Hanging,” as Orwell observes a man marching toward the gallows, it is the small gesture of the man swerving to avoid a puddle that brings him to life. This is much like the scene in War and Peace where Pierre, in line to be executed, notices a man in front of him adjusting his blindfold to make himself more comfortable. One of these stories is made up, and one may have happened. In both instances, it is the fine details that bring the scene to life and drive home the powerful images of humanity.

Leslie observed that the reader can see more if there is not too much. She gave the example of Picasso’s creature drawn from three lines. She noted that being a reader of fiction has caused her to observe the world differently, that scenes in real life can often seem like part of a novel, reminding us that for each person we see, there is so much more that doesn’t meet the eye.

James asked Leslie what it was like for her over the last two to three years to be working on fiction. She answered, “It feels great.” Leslie’s first book was a novel, and she described that she found a kind of freedom when she shifted to essays and memoirs. She has found the shift back to fiction “like a boomerang, but extravagantly freeing.”

The inspiration for her new novel came as she was reading to her four-year-old daughter the story of the Minotaur and the Labyrinth. In this version of the story, the minotaur was a baby, and her daughter asked if the baby’s mother would go with her into the labyrinth. The answer was no. The image of a child wandering about in the darkness of this world, a darkness from which the parent cannot protect them, she knew that it would be through fiction that she could get to the “vitality” of the story, where it would feel most alive. She sought to explore themes she has always explored in her nonfiction as well and noted that fairy tales can hold our darkest fears, which is why we read them.

When Leslie asked James about his experience writing the memoir of his father, he described it as a wonderful writing experience, where it was easier to hold onto the railing of his father’s actual life than to write a fictional narrative. He noted that fiction and nonfiction have different liberties and limitations. The limitation of nonfiction is that you are writing about something that has happened rather than something that has not happened. There is an “ongoingness to the memoir project that doesn’t come into fiction.” Fiction must come to an end. Something has to stop, which is why, in fiction workshops, we speak about endings and why endings challenge us.

Both James Wood and Leslie Jamison have achieved mastery in the writing craft. Listening to them speak about their new projects, which crossover between fiction and nonfiction, gave those of us in the audience new insights, made clearer by the contrasts.

 

Bobbie Marquis earned her MFA degree from the Naslund-Mann School of Writing at Spalding University. She is the executive director of the Johann Fust Library Foundation in Boca Grande, Florida, where she produces an author series and publishes “Island Booknotes,” a magazine of poetry, essays, book reviews, short fiction, and a catalog of the foundation’s literary events.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>